Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3: The Black Order Review – Should You Play It?

It’s been a decade since Ultimate Alliance 2 released for just about every box you could play games on in 2009. And with Marvel being the absolute powerhouse it is today, Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3 has been granted some luxuries that previous installments weren’t, such as an established cinematic universe to mine from, resulting in what feels like a hodgepodge of MCU storylines and comic-book lore. With more superhero cameos than even Avengers Endgame, the game is best described as a digital manifestation of the term “fan service”.

That’s not to say that MUA 3 isn’t a fun time, after all, this is a game where you can combine your favorite Marvel characters to create a four-man/woman/alien/whatever Ghost Rider is wrecking crew and destroy the forces of evil, aka anyone that looks even slightly sketchy. I spent the better half of the 6-10 hour campaign mindlessly ripping apart evil doers with a giant, invisible grin on my face as many of my favorite childhood superheroes adorned my Switch’s screen.

However, there are some noticeable flaws with MUA 3 when it comes to performance and a number of its progression systems. In this review, I’ll be assessing areas that I think the game excels at along with some letdowns and a few minor gripes before wrapping things up with an overall score.

Colliding Universes

Marvel Ultimate Alliance

MUA 3 plays it relatively safe when it comes to its narrative, placing the Infinity Stones at the center of the game’s plot. Just like in the comics and most recent phase of the MCU, we see The Avengers and friends working together to prevent Thanos and his cronies from acquiring all six stones and destroying the universe. Throughout the heroes’ journey, the player is transported to a number of iconic Marvel locations such as The Avengers Tower, the X-Mansion, Wakanda, Asgard, and more. 

Marvel Black Order

I found each setting to be detailed-enough to set them apart from the rest and further elevated by the fully-voiced characters that resided within them. Although by the end I found myself skipping through a lot of the dialogue, there are plenty of stand-out exchanges between characters referencing events from Marvel films and even a few nods to the recently-cancelled live-action Netflix shows. The story is structured so that you’re constantly encountering new characters and weaving new narrative threads, resulting in what feels like an entertaining and brisk stroll through Marvel’s connected universes.

Brawling and Crawling

Marvel The Black Order

MUA 3 most closely resembles a Diablo-style dungeon crawler in which you explore sprawling maps filled with enemies, collectibles, and loot. It borrows a lot from the previous games, and sees each hero using a combination of light and heavy attacks along with four special abilities assigned to each face button. Additionally, you can perform synergy attacks with other members of your party for extra damage and charge up a meter for Extreme Attacks, which see your hero going all out and using their most powerful abilities.

I found that if you chained together all four party members Extreme Attacks, two interesting things would happen; first, you’d unleash a boatload of damage on every enemy nearby; and second, the Switch’s frame rate would drop abysmally low. This was disappointing given that MUA 3 was developed solely for the Switch and therefore, should be fully optimized for the console.

Performance issues aside, I found the gameplay to be enjoyable. The difficulty ramps up fairly quickly and you may see yourself having to replay a few boss fights if you’re not actively dodging or blocking. Hack n’ slash games have a tendency to feel like a mindless chore, and while I’d say that definitely applies to MUA 3, the game also has enough going on to keep you engaged; when you’re not fighting, you’re solving some light puzzles or navigating through platforming sections.

Order Nintendo Switch

When it comes to the game’s progression system, I found left something to be desired; over the course of the story, you collect shards that can be equipped to any hero in order to obtain passive buffs that enhance your hero’s traits. This system feels like something you’d expect to see in a mobile title and doesn’t do a great job at making you feel like you’re improving or becoming stronger.

The same can be said about the Alliance Enhancement skill tree, which allows you to purchase permanent buffs that apply to your entire party. Broken up into 7 sections, these serve as nothing more than monetary checkboxes you’ll find yourself buying any time you come across an especially tough boss fight. The issue seems to stem from the hero traits themselves, of which there are six (Strength, Vitality, Durability, Resilience, Mastery, and Energy), which are also never fully explained to the player.

Forming New Alliances

Marvel Alliance

I spent the first half of the campaign playing in local co-op with one other player, and the other half completely solo. I was shocked to see the detrimental effect playing locally had on the game’s performance, given the couch co-op appeal of the series. MUA 3 doesn’t include split-screen co-op, with the action taking place on one screen and a tight restriction on how far apart players can be.

Black Order

This proved frustrating whenever I or my teammate were caught up in our own scuffles slightly off-screen. What made it worse is neither player is granted control over the camera, limiting your field of view to whatever area the fixed camera is currently pointed at. Thankfully, this issue isn’t present when playing online.

The Final Verdict

Switch Reviews

Although my time with MUA 3 may have been plagued by performance issues and confusing progression systems, there were brief moments where I was reminded of what it was like to play earlier Ultimate Alliance games. Perhaps MUA 3 is nothing more than an attempt to recreate an era of gaming that has long since passed; or maybe I’ve just evolved as a gamer, spoiled by the amenities offered by more modern titles. 

I’d consider MUA 3 to be the kind of game you pick up on sale and play when you’re in the mood for some mindless action; one where you maybe lower the volume, put on some music or a podcast, and watch as your simple button inputs translate into flashy combos on screen.

The Pros

  • Eye-catching visuals
  • Roster of 30+ playable characters
  • Satisfying combat

The Cons

  • Inconsistent frame-rates
  • Confusing progression systems
  • Lack of local split-screen
  • Clunky camera controls
Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3: The Black Order Review
  • 6.5/10
    Overall - 6.5/10
6.5/10

Summary

Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3 may not live up to the nostalgia of its namesake but it’s still a solid dungeon crawler that offers tons of replayability thanks to well-designed environments, a large roster of playable characters, and numerous modifiers. While some parts feel extremely dated by today’s standards, MUA 3 offers mindless, dungeon crawling fun for any superhero fan.

You Might Also Be Interested In These